• Data tracker

Students and parents plead case for homework ban

Students And Parents Plead Case For Homework Ban

School children and parents pleaded with the Minister for Education Norma Foley to step in and introduce a homework ban.

In letters to the minister, kids wrote about how they were being forced to give up hobbies because they were given so much work to do after school.

The correspondence followed comments by President Michael D Higgins in January that a ban on homework should be considered.

In one letter, a school child wrote about how seven hours of school each day was “plenty of education” and that more work on top was unnecessary.

“I do not ask for homework to be completely banned but for it to be reduced to a certain limit. Otherwise, if there is a constant build-up of homework daily, it can cause stress and even a lack of exercise which will affect a person’s well-being.”

Another said they felt homework was a “waste of time” and that a ban should be introduced.

They wrote: “Kids should be doing more creative things with their time after school. Many kids have had to stop doing hobbies they have because of it.

“It is a burden to parents, kids, and teachers [and] so for the above reasons, I think you should BAN HOMEWORK!”

Homework annoys teachers

One hand-written letter, decorated with a Minnie Mouse bow, said homework was “annoying for teachers and pupils”.

“I play soccer and love writing stories, but because of homework, I have no time for doing these things. For teachers, it gives them more copies to correct and they have to go through the trouble of deciding what [homework] to give.”

A secondary school student said that if “sleeping isn’t for school” then “work isn’t for home”.

They explained how they did between one and two hours of homework every evening after school and sometimes more.

“When I would finish, there would be barely any time for me to relax before I had to go to bed to get enough sleep to get up in the morning,” said their letter.

“As I’m sure you’re aware, our president Michael D Higgins also thinks that homework should be banned so if you don’t want to listen to me, listen to our President.”

Another suggested there could at least be a compromise so that students would not be given homework for over the weekend.

“[This would relieve] students of mental stress,” they said.

Help parents

One young student said they were left with no time to help their parents, or to learn how to cook or do other activities around the house.

They said: “We all do activities like swimming, dance, and all other sports. It’s hard work and it’s stressful and it’s unfair.”

A single parent also wrote in to explain how one of their children was getting two hours of written homework every day.

They said: “We need time to teach them life skills such as sewing, cooking, how to work the washing machine, change their own bed sheets and personal care.

“These teachings are very hard for parents with zero [time] left in the evenings. There is no time for them to spend with siblings and parents because they are so tired.”

Majority Of Workers In Favour Of Four-Day Work Week

In responses, the Department of Education told the letter writers that homework policy was not within its powers.

In emails, they said: “The Department does not issue direct guidelines relating to homework being given in schools. It is a matter for each school, at local level, to arrive at its own homework policy.

“In keeping with good practice, the process of drafting a homework policy should involve consultation with teachers, parents, and students.

“However, the Department does acknowledge that homework can play an important part in helping pupils prepare for forthcoming class work and in reinforcing work already covered during class time.”

  • Education ,
  • Norma Foley ,
  • President Michael D Higgins ,
  • Minister for Education ,
  • homework ban

Higgins And Mcdonald Attend Palestinian Women’s Team Match In Dublin

Higgins and McDonald attend Palestinian women’s team match in Dublin

Luas Delays: Power Outage Causes Major Disruption

Luas delays: Power outage causes major disruption

Man (23) Jailed For Sexually Assaulting His Friend At Her Home

Man (23) jailed for sexually assaulting his friend at her home

Arlene Foster Denies 'Sectarianising' Stormont’s Response To Covid-19

Arlene Foster denies 'sectarianising' Stormont’s response to Covid-19

Higgins And Mcdonald Attend Palestinian Women’s Team Match In Dublin

Message submitting... Thank you for waiting.

Want us to email you top stories each lunch time?

IAB logo

President Michael D Higgins says homework should be banned in Ireland

The country’s favourite leader believes that school activities should end at the school gate and students should be encouraged to engage in more creative pursuits

  • 10:39, 21 JAN 2023

President Michael D Higgins

Never miss a beat from Dublin and beyond by signing up to our FREE newsletter

We have more newsletters

President Michael D Higgins has called for homework to be banned.

The country’s favourite leader has given hope to a new generation of students that the bane of their afterschool evenings could be scrapped. President Higgins argues that this would make time for young people to engage in more creative pursuits outside school hours.

The former Arts Minister believes that school activities should end at the school gate. He was speaking to RTE’s news2day current affairs and news programme for children on the occasion of the programme’s 20th birthday.

Read more: Children being 'corrupted' by drug dealing situation in Oliver Bond flats, Dail told

When asked what his opinion of homework President Higgins said: “I think myself, really that the time at home, and the time in the school is an educational experience and it should get finished at the school and people should be able to use their time for other creative things.”

To mark the show’s two decades on air, students from St Kevin’s National School, Littleton, County Tipperary put questions from RTÉ news2day viewers to President Higgins at Áras an Uachtaráin. In a wide-ranging interview, the children asked the President questions like, what was your favourite sport when you were in school?

When you were nine years old what did you want to be? And when did you decide you wanted to be President?

The students also asked the President about his dogs, his official trips abroad, his favourite subject in school, differences between now and when he was a child and his favourite book. The President also spoke to the children about his love of handball and the importance of friendship in their lives.

RTÉ news2day will broadcast some of the President’s interview as part of Friday afternoon’s birthday celebrations at 4.20pm on RTÉ2 and RTÉ News channel and the full interview will be available later on Friday evening on the RTÉ Player. In a message to the children of Ireland and the viewers of RTÉ news2day, President Michael D. Higgins gave this advice: “To stay curious about everything and I think it’s important to make sure you don’t miss the joy of sharing information.

“And I think an important thing is friendship and to make sure that there’s no one left without friendship and that people belong. And we will all do individual things... but I think friendships that you make will in fact always be great memories and that is so important. And also have the courage to stand your own ground and let other children be allowed the space of standing their ground too because none of us are the same.

“We’re all unique but at the same time we have a lot going for us.” President Higgins also encouraged the children of Ireland to speak the Irish language.

He encouraged them to speak Irish in a fun way and to feel free to use whatever bits of the language that they have.

Phone analysis expert says 'nothing to suggest' Jonathan Dowdall in park on alleged 'confession' date

Dermot Bannon says latest season of Room To Improve 'nearly killed him'

RTE Late Late Show viewers hail 'fantastic' Nell Mescal on singing debut

Temperatures soar across Dublin despite forecast of dreary weather

Gardai appeal for help in locating missing Dublin pensioner

Sign up to the Dublin Live Newsletter to get all the latest Dublin news straight to your inbox.

  • President Higgins
  • Most Recent

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

UK Edition Change

  • UK Politics
  • News Videos
  • Paris 2024 Olympics
  • Rugby Union
  • Sport Videos
  • John Rentoul
  • Mary Dejevsky
  • Andrew Grice
  • Sean O’Grady
  • Photography
  • Theatre & Dance
  • Culture Videos
  • Fitness & Wellbeing
  • Food & Drink
  • Health & Families
  • Royal Family
  • Electric Vehicles
  • Car Insurance Deals
  • Lifestyle Videos
  • UK Hotel Reviews
  • News & Advice
  • Simon Calder
  • Australia & New Zealand
  • South America
  • C. America & Caribbean
  • Middle East
  • Politics Explained
  • News Analysis
  • Today’s Edition
  • Home & Garden
  • Broadband deals
  • Fashion & Beauty
  • Travel & Outdoors
  • Sports & Fitness
  • Sustainable Living
  • Climate Videos
  • Solar Panels
  • Behind The Headlines
  • On The Ground
  • Decomplicated
  • You Ask The Questions
  • Binge Watch
  • Travel Smart
  • Watch on your TV
  • Crosswords & Puzzles
  • Most Commented
  • Newsletters
  • Ask Me Anything
  • Virtual Events
  • Betting Sites
  • Online Casinos
  • Wine Offers

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in Please refresh your browser to be logged in

President of Ireland calls on schools to stop giving pupils homework

Children should be able to use time at home ‘for other creative things’, says michael d higgins, article bookmarked.

Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile

Michael D Higgins says schools should not continue after final bell

Schools should strive not to give pupils homework where possible, the president of Ireland has suggested.

In an utterance likely to be seized upon by children for years to come, in classrooms far beyond the shores of the Emerald Isle, Michael D Higgins argued that school should not extend beyond the final bell.

“Time in school … should get finished in school,” the president told pupils at a school in County Tipperary this week during a broadcast for RTE.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article

Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.

New to The Independent?

Or if you would prefer:

Want an ad-free experience?

Hi {{indy.fullName}}

  • My Independent Premium
  • Account details
  • Help centre

President Michael D Higgins calls for school homework to be scrapped

President Michael D Higgins stopped by St Kevin's National School in Tipperary where the pupils interviewed him about his dogs, his time in school and his view on homework

  • 15:01, 21 JAN 2023

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

Get the latest showbiz news and gossip every day by signing up to our FREE newsletter

We have more newsletters

President of Ireland Michael D Higgins has said he supports the scrapping of homework.

He addressed students of St Kevin's National School, Littleton, Co Tipperary, this week in an episode of RTE's news2day programme.

The President said that schoolwork should be completed in school time so children can use time after school to pursue more creative activities.

Read more: Ireland weather: Met Eireann pin point the end of the cold snap as temperatures skyrocket next week

“People should be able to use their time for other creative things,” he said.

"I think as much as possible that [homework] should happen in the school and I think it’s more relaxed than it used to be.”

He said that not all lessons are learned from books, but that the responsible use of phones is something that he hopes the younger generation will be acutely aware of.

The children of Ireland "have a great value of friendships" and this makes it even more tragic when there is an "abuse of phones for bullying", the President said.

The pupils were also curious about some of the other residents of Aras an Uachtaran - dogs Brod and Misneach.

"He's probably a very famous dog now," said President Higgins of Brod. "He will be 11 in February, which is a very good age for a Bernese Mountain dog and Bród is wonderful.

"He came here at six weeks old, so he's lived all of his life at the Áras..

As for Misneach, he said: "He came during Covid and because I couldn't collect him because of the ban on inter-county travel, he didn't come to me until he was five months old.

"He also didn't have a good journey here, so he's actually shy. He's a beautiful dog."

Get the latest RSVP headlines straight to your inbox for free by signing up to our newsletter

Social welfare Ireland: Major warning issued as payment dates change ahead of Bank Holiday

Louth nurse opens up about father's passing 10 days after cancer diagnosis

Stefanie Preissner felt enormous guilt after 5 devastating miscarriages in two years

Una Healy leaves fans 'mind blown' after capturing optical illusion photograph

Amy Huberman moved after young fan sends her sweet letter

  • Most Recent

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

  • Reader view

School Curriculum

Dáil Éireann Debate, Wednesday - 24 March 2021

Wednesday, 24 March 2021

Questions (845).

Holly Cairns

Holly Cairns

845. Deputy Holly Cairns asked the Minister for Education the position regarding the pedagogical value of homework for primary and post-primary students; the way in which research in the field informs teaching and learning practices; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [14326/21]

Written answers

Norma Foley

Minister for Education

The Department of Education does not issue any guidelines relating to homework being given in schools. It is a matter for each school, at local level to arrive at its own homework policy. In keeping with good practice, the process of drafting a homework policy should involve consultation with teachers, parents and students.

Although schools are not obliged to have a published policy on homework the Department does acknowledge that homework can play an important part in helping students to prepare for forthcoming classwork and in reinforcing work already covered during class time.

For those students/pupils that are still learning remotely, teachers should ensure that pupils are given opportunities to make real progress in developing their knowledge, skills and understanding across the curriculum. Guidance from the Department states that it is important that all teachers provide specific teaching input to their students/pupils to support them as they continue their learning engagement, this will vary between the work that the teacher will ask students/pupils to do independently and direct teaching by the teacher.

In relation to research on homework, the National Council for Curriculum and Assessment (NCCA), in consultation with the National Parents Council, commissioned some research in 2018 on Parental Involvement, Engagement and Partnership in their Children’s Education during the Primary School Years with Homework a significant theme in this work. This research was published in 2019 and is available on the NCCA website: www.mie.ie/en/research/parental_involvement_engagement_and_partnership_in_their_children%E2%80%99s_education_during_the_primary_school_years/ .

Homework is see as promoting a partnership between the school, the child and the parents The research  looked at the following areas ?  

- The home learning environment

- The role of homework

- Homework and achievement

- Parental involvement with homework

Children’s voice on homework

In terms of recommendations related to homework, the following are detailed:

- Additional opportunities could be provided for parents and teachers to discuss how to support children’s language development in the home. This could begin with a conversation about homework

- Although there is evidence of good homework practice in schools, there is a need for national guidance on homework in relation to time, content and method that suits children best, according to research in the field

- Schools need to review homework policies and to ensure a whole-school approach is applied in relation to homework

- Entertaining and interactive oral language games and activities should be incorporated into children’s homework

- In planning homework, schools might take into consideration the demands on children's time to do planned activities outside of school and the importance of outdoor free play opportunities for young children

- Schools might consider removing homework from junior infant classes with the exception of story-time/reading to/with children

- Colleges of Education might consider a module on parental involvement in their children’s education and to include a focus on homework in the module. This is already happening in some Colleges of Education.

This research is being  taken under consideration in the review and redevelopment of the Primary Curriculum currently underway by the NCCA.

Post Primary

The Framework for Junior Cycle (2015) outlines a comprehensive range of approaches to teaching, learning, and assessment which has been informed by engagement with the educational partners and by national and international research. This includes an approach to assessment which emphasises that the primary purpose of assessment at this stage of students’ school lives should be the support of learning. In this context, the Framework advises that teachers and students engage in ongoing assessment activities as part of classroom practice that can be either formative or summative in nature.

Schools are to use a range of assessment methods for formative and summative purposes which emphasise the interlinked and complementary nature of the assessment process at junior cycle. The Framework highlights that students’ homework assignments, project work, and tasks will each have significant formative potential as the teacher gives regular feedback to students on their work. They will also provide opportunities for teachers to take stock and make judgements about how well a student is progressing in their learning.

In addition, the National Council for Curriculum and Assessment (NCCA) has supported significant research into students’ experiences of senior cycle education, including homework. The Council is currently completing its review of senior cycle education which will be informed by this research. One of the units explores how developing student reflection can allow students to take more responsibility for their own learning and progress. It presents lots of strategies that you can use or adapt when helping students to reflect on their learning. While it doesn’t reference homework, supporting students to reflect on learning should underpin the design of homework tasks.

  • Previous Answer
  • Next Answer

President of Ireland calls for homework to be banned

 President of Ireland Michael D Higgins.

President of Ireland Michael D Higgins. (Source: Getty)

The President of Ireland has made his thoughts known about homework, saying it should be left at the gate and children should be able to use their leisure time for "creative things".

Speaking to RTE’s news2day - a current affairs and news programme for children, Michael D Higgins answered questions on a wide range of topics, the Irish Mirror reports .

When pressed on his views about homework Higgins said: “I think myself, really that the time at home, and the time in the school is an educational experience and it should get finished at the school and people should be able to use their time for other creative things.”

Higgins, a former arts minister, told children “to stay curious about everything and I think it’s important to make sure you don’t miss the joy of sharing information.

“And I think an important thing is friendship and to make sure that there’s no one left without friendship and that people belong. And we will all do individual things... but I think friendships that you make will in fact always be great memories and that is so important.

“And also have the courage to stand your own ground and let other children be allowed the space of standing their ground too because none of us are the same.

“We’re all unique but at the same time we have a lot going for us.”

Higgins also encouraged the children of Ireland to speak the Irish language.

While the role of president in Ireland is mainly a ceremonial one, it does have some sway over how the government operates.

More Stories

Rescue workers wheel Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico, who was shot and injured, to a hospital in the town of Banska Bystrica, central Slovakia.

Slovakia's populist PM fights for life after shooting

The pro-Russian leader Robert Fico, 59, was shot multiple times and hit in the stomach.

58 mins ago

This picture provided by Interpol shows Mohamed Amra, a convict that escaped from prison.

All of France is looking for him: Who is 'The Fly'?

Mohamed Amra, 30, has a long and violent criminal history that has now culminated in a high-profile search.

French President Emmanuel Macron.

Macron convenes top ministers amid unrest in New Caledonia

Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky, left, greets US Secretary of State Antony Blinken, right, prior to their meeting in Kyiv, Ukraine.

Russia says it downed 10 US-supplied missiles over Crimea

People view the live stream portal between Dublin and New York, in Dublin, Ireland.

New York-Dublin 'portal' plagued by bad behaviour

Investigators at the scene of the attack in Normandy, northern France.

Two officers killed, inmate escapes in France prison van ambush

Wed, May 15

Under threat of jail, beekeeper burns $2m of bee boxes

Govt's quarterly report card: Is the coalition meeting its KPIs?

New school lunch model could cut out kaupapa Māori suppliers

The most energy-efficient options to heat your home this winter

Lotto Powerball jackpot rolls over to $23 million

Premier League clubs to discuss proposal to scrap VAR

Premier League clubs to discuss proposal to scrap VAR

39 mins ago

Florida bus crash: Man pleads not guilty after eight die

A bus is removed after it collided with a small pickup truck killing eight of the more than 50 migrant workers in the bus.

Fifty firefighters contain factory fire in Auckland's Takanini

A large fire has been contained in Auckland's Takanini this morning.

Cyclone Gabrielle: Emergency failures revealed in damning self-review

Flood damage in Napier following Cyclone Gabrielle

How to boost your retirement nest egg

Sponsored by Fisher Funds

How to boost your retirement nest egg

More from Entertainment

Kiwi band pushes deeper into the south than ever before, to a delighted packed hall of locals.

Six60 rocks Stewart Island, grassroots Australia next up

Kiwi band pushes deeper into the south than ever before, to a delighted packed hall of locals.

Ellen DeGeneres.

Ellen DeGeneres to address TV show scandal in Netflix special

The comedian's long-running programme, The Ellen DeGeneres Show, was marred by accusations of toxic behaviour in 2020.

Actor Paul Giamatti.

Paul Giamatti joins cast for filming of Downton Abbey 3

Tuesday 5:03pm

The Block NZ cancelled, houses to be completed and sold

The Block NZ cancelled, houses to be completed and sold

Tuesday 4:02pm

Joost Klein of Netherlands arrives on stage for the introducing of the artists at the dress rehearsal for the final at the Eurovision Song Contest in Malmo, Sweden.

Eurovision: Dutch artist expelled from contest likely to face charges

Tuesday 8:09am

Donald Glover, who goes by the stage name Childish Gambino, performs at the Governors Ball Music Festival in New York on June 3, 2017.

Childish Gambino announces NZ show as part of world tour

Tuesday 6:33am

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

Norma Foley won't debate homework with President Michael Higgins after his call for it to be banned

Minister Foley finally broke her silence on the matter last night when she told the Irish Mirror that she was not going to get into it with the President.

  • 06:00, 26 JAN 2023
  • Updated 09:54, 26 JAN 2023

Norma Foley

Want the latest political news and analysis delivered straight to your inbox? Sign up to our FREE newsletter

We have more newsletters

Education Minister Norma Foley is refusing to debate the homework ban issue with Michael D Higgins after the President called for schoolwork outside of school hours to be scrapped.

Instead, she said it is up to schools to decide homework policy, which is at odds with the President’s call for schoolwork to be left at the school gate.

The controversial comments, made on RTE’s news2day children’s news programme, have had the country’s students, teachers and parents debating the issue since the remarks were made last Friday by the President.

READ MORE: Met Eireann verdict on Ireland ‘Polar Vortex’ fears as weather phenomenon could trigger big freeze

She said: “It would not be appropriate for a Government Minister to engage in public debate with the office of the President.

“Currently schools are free to have their own policy on homework and these policies are created in conjunction with senior management and staff, the boards of management, parents and the pupils.

“Schools are in of themselves places where creative pursuits are cultivated, nurtured and encouraged and that creativity may also be reflected in homework.”

Meanwhile, a Government Minister has said that it is “important” to include children in discussions about homework policies in schools.

It comes days after President Higgins’ call for homework to be banned at home and for all work to stay in the classroom.

Irish Mirror readers were also overwhelmingly in favour of banning homework, with 98% of our readers in favour.

In a landslide decision, 57,440 readers voted yes, while just 1,211 voted no.

In an interview with RTÉ’s news2day, President Higgins said that he believed that time at home should be spent doing more creative activities,

He said: “I think myself, really that the time at home, and the time in the school is an educational experience and it should get finished at the school and people should be able to use their time for other creative things."

Minister Foley recently said that her Department does “not issue any guidelines relating to homework being given in schools.

“It is a matter for each school, at local level, to arrive at its own homework policy”.

It followed a question from Fine Gael Minister of State Neale Richmond who asked if research has been carried out by her Department into the benefits of ending the provision of homework for primary school pupils.

He told the Irish Mirror that children should be involved in conversations about their schools homework policy.

Minister Richmond said: “I submitted the Parliamentary Question following a visit to one of my local primary schools.

“The pupils were genuinely interested in the policy relating to homework going forward and I agreed it’s an important discussion to involve pupils in.”

Minister Foley told her Government colleague that the Department of Education has not commissioned research on the matter.

Heartbroken father says daughter made him pay for wedding before 'replacing me on the big day'

Thousands of workers missing out on cash boost that could be worth over €2,000

Instagram users warned 'you might have a stalker' if you notice one strange thing on your stories

Major rescue operation called into action after person falls from cliff in Howth

€3.5m Lotto jackpot-winning ticket sold in Dublin as search begins for winner

Get breaking news to your inbox by signing up to our newsletter

  • President Higgins
  • Most Recent

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

Banning homework: Norma Foley won't debate homework issue with President Michael D. Higgins

Michael D Higgins suggested that school activities should end at the school gates

  • 08:28, 27 JAN 2023
  • Updated 13:12, 20 JUL 2023

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

Stay on top of the latest issues at home and abroad by signing up to our FREE daily newsletter

We have more newsletters

Minister for Education, Norma Foley, has said she won't debate the homework ban issue with President Michael D Higgins.

School policy on homework

Last week, Higgins told the nation's children that he was against schoolwork continuing beyond the school gates, in an address broadcast on RTÉ's news2day.

Foley said it was up to schools to decide on their homework policy.

She told The Irish Mirror that she wasn't going to get into it with the president.

"It would not be appropriate for a government minister to engage in public debate with the office of the president," she said.

"Currently schools are free to have their own policy on homework and these policies are created in conjunction with senior management and staff, the boards of management, parents and the pupils.

"Schools are in of themselves places where creative pursuits are cultivated, nurtured and encouraged and that creativity may also be reflected in homework."

Support for banning homework

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

Meanwhile, a government minister has said that it is "important" to include children in discussions about homework policies in schools.

Irish Mirror readers were also overwhelmingly in favour of banning homework, with 98 per cent of readers voting in favour of a ban.

In a landslide decision, 57,440 readers voted yes, while just 1,211 voted no.

Speaking on RTÉ last week, Higgins argued that getting rid of homework would allow young people more time to engage in creative pursuits outside of school hours.

The president was asked for his thoughts on homework and responded that he wasn't in favour of it.

"I think myself, really that the time at home, and the time in the school is an educational experience and it should get finished at the school and people should be able to use their time for other creative things."

Benefits of homework

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

Minister Foley recently said that her department doesn't "issue any guidelines relating to homework being given in schools.

"It is a matter for each school, at local level, to arrive at its own homework policy".

It followed a question from Fine Gael's Neale Richmond who asked if research has been carried out by her department into the benefits of ending the provision of homework for primary school pupils.

He told The Irish Mirror that children should be involved in conversations about their schools homework policy.

Minister Richmond said: "I submitted the Parliamentary Question following a visit to one of my local primary schools.

"The pupils were genuinely interested in the policy relating to homework going forward and I agreed it's an important discussion to involve pupils in."

Foley told her government colleague that the Department of Education has not commissioned research on the matter.

To keep up to date with all the latest Irish environment and international climate news sign up to our bi-weekly newsletter

READ NEXT - The environmental wins and losses of 2022

READ NEXT - The top political stories in Ireland in 2022

  • In the News
  • Michael D Higgins
  • Norma Foley
  • Most Recent

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

  • Travel + Fun
  • KeepDiscovering
  • About HerFamily
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Statement
  • Advertise With Us
  • User Generated Content
  • Lovin Dublin

14th Mar 2023

Pupils and parents call on government to introduce homework ban

Kat O'Connor

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

Is it time to ban homework in Ireland?

Parents and pupils are calling on Minister for Education Norma Foley to ban homework in Ireland.

Many parents have voiced their concerns about the level of homework their kids get, but they’re taking it a step further by writing to the Education Minister.

Foley has received multiple letters from both children and parents about why a homework ban is needed.

According to The Irish Examiner , children revealed that homework is having a negative impact on their lives outside of school.

Many pupils believe they do enough work in school and stressed that there is little benefit to spending hours doing homework in the evenings.

One child wrote;

“I do not ask for homework to be completely banned but for it to be reduced to a certain limit. Otherwise, if there is a constant build-up of homework daily, it can cause stress and even a lack of exercise which will affect a person’s well-being.”

Norma Foley homework ban

Many children told Foley that homework was “a waste of time”. Others said it was a “burden to parents, kids, and teachers.”

Varadkar said homework should not be banned completely

Both Leo Varadkar and Michael D. Higgins have expressed concerns about the amount of homework children are getting in Ireland.

However, Varadkar does not believe in a complete ban on homework.

He previously said there’s a place for homework in our education system, but we need to have a fair balance.

“You could have a long day in class, get home in the early evening, and then face, you know, three hours of homework.

“I remember that when I was a kid, staying up very late to do homework,” he shared.

Varadkar stressed that it shouldn’t be banned completely, but scaled back.

President Higgins also voiced his concerns about homework

The President of Ireland agreed with parents and said children should have more free time after school.

He told RTÉ’s news2day: “I think myself, really that the time at home and the time in school is an educational experience and it should get finished at the school and people should be able to use their time for other creative things.”

Do you think homework should be banned in Ireland?

Related Links:

Parents call for homework to be banned in ireland, varadkar agrees that children are getting too much homework, foley responds to homework ban calls and parents are furious, related articles.

5 things you shouldn’t pack in your child’s lunch box

5 things you shouldn’t pack in your child’s lunch box

By Anna Martin

Mum who admits to doing children’s homework for them draws criticism

Mum who admits to doing children’s homework for them draws criticism

By Jody Coffey

‘My son’s nose was broken in school and they didn’t call me about it’

‘My son’s nose was broken in school and they didn’t call me about it’

By Kat O'Connor

5 things you shouldn’t pack in your child’s lunch box

MORE FROM HerFamily

These parenting apps are essential for keeping your children safe online

cybersecurity

These parenting apps are essential for keeping your children safe online

By Sophie Collins

Dad hits back after vile trolls slam him for kissing his 5-year-old son on lips

Dad hits back after vile trolls slam him for kissing his 5-year-old son on lips

By HerFamily

Is ‘picky eating’ unacceptable past childhood?

Is ‘picky eating’ unacceptable past childhood?

By Niamh Ryan

Swimming coach warns parents not to put towel around kids’ shoulders

Swimming coach warns parents not to put towel around kids’ shoulders

This hack will make it so much easier to keep your child safe in a crowd

child safety

This hack will make it so much easier to keep your child safe in a crowd

Psychologist lists five phrases parents should avoid with kids and why

expert advice

Psychologist lists five phrases parents should avoid with kids and why

People with these ‘powerhouse names’ are more likely to be successful, according to science

People with these ‘powerhouse names’ are more likely to be successful, according to science

‘I’m a coeliac, how can I tell if my baby has the same allergy?’

‘I’m a coeliac, how can I tell if my baby has the same allergy?’

Mum calls out nursery for shortening daughter’s name because it’s ‘too difficult to pronounce’

Mum calls out nursery for shortening daughter’s name because it’s ‘too difficult to pronounce’

By Charlie Herbert

Man who says he’s secret son of King Charles and Camilla shares ‘uncanny’ photo of daughter to prove it

King Charles

Man who says he’s secret son of King Charles and Camilla shares ‘uncanny’ photo of daughter to prove it

Nappy rash: What causes it, how to prevent it and how to treat it

Nappy rash: What causes it, how to prevent it and how to treat it

It’s a boy! Ant McPartlin announces the birth of his first child

ant mcpartlin

It’s a boy! Ant McPartlin announces the birth of his first child

Two-year-old with ‘0 per cent chance of survival’ after burning 98 per cent of his body is now inspiring others

Two-year-old with ‘0 per cent chance of survival’ after burning 98 per cent of his body is now inspiring others

By Nina McLaughlin

Carl Mullan opens up about the complexities of fatherhood

Carl Mullan opens up about the complexities of fatherhood

Government approves plans to raise the age of sale of tobacco to 21 in Ireland

Government approves plans to raise the age of sale of tobacco to 21 in Ireland

‘They need you less and they push back’ – How to navigate life with a teenager

‘They need you less and they push back’ – How to navigate life with a teenager

One Irish baby name deemed ‘extinct’ in Ireland is hugely popular in US

One Irish baby name deemed ‘extinct’ in Ireland is hugely popular in US

Check out the latest episode of our interview podcast, Unfiltered

Subscribe free:

Listen on Apple Podcasts

We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

  • Temperature Check
  • The Stardust Inquests
  • Inside The Newsroom
  • Climate Crisis
  • International

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

'Why I believe homework should be banned', by one primary school student

As the discussion around state exams through the Covid-19 shutdown continues, a separate debate about the very need for homework itself rumbles on. Over the years, many have argued that homework for students in busy modern-day family structures is no longer workable.

This year, the Green Party sought to open a discussion about the banning of homework in future. Here, primary school pupil Misha McEnaney, a fifth class student from Dublin, outlines why he believes homework is more of a hindrance than a help.

IRISH CHILDREN SPEND around 274.5 hours on homework in a year. Is it a waste of time? Generally speaking, homework does not improve academic performance among children, although it may improve academic skills among older students especially lower-achieving kids. Homework also creates stress among students who could be doing other things.

I think it is a waste of time. Here’s why I think so. 

Many students think homework is extremely boring and hard so it increases our stress levels. You might fight with your family or friends and that gives the impression you are angry and irritated when often it’s just because your homework is increasing your stress.

Also, a study by scholar Denise Pope at Stanford shows that out of 4,300 students at high-performance schools, 60% stated that their homework was their primary source of stress.

Movement is more important

I believe that homework eliminates time when you could be exercising, playing sports, carrying out hobbies, reading etc. So when your friends are playing outside or something exciting or important is happening you can’t go out because you’re stuck inside doing your homework. 

Homework messes up your sleep cycles and it causes you to be more tired. After school when you’re tired from working you still have to do your homework, so you don’t deliver your full concentration and that makes your performance not as acceptable as it should be. This can cause your grade to go down and so that defeats the whole point of education to become better and smarter. 

A study from teenink.com shows that students perform best in school when they receive 10–12 hours of sleep each night, while only 15% of teenagers in America reported themselves sleeping eight hours or more on school nights, according to the national sleep foundation of America. Sleep disruption is very bad for our health.

Teacher trust

If you’re completely booked up for the day doing sports or other activities you have no time to do your homework. Your teachers start to trust you less and less and this develops a bad view of you when it’s not entirely your fault. 

It’s also repetitive so you’re doing the same work at school and there’s no effectiveness, it’s not going in. So all that homework becomes a waste because you have already completed it at school. You can also easily get distracted.

Homework takes away revision time for tests and that can affect the test scores. That develops a bad reputation for the student and for the school. The parents then assume that the teaching at the school is bad and they might move school. So the kid might lose friends and over time the school becomes less liked and popular.

All because there is too much homework. 

Bad for the mood

If you don’t sleep enough it can cause mood swings which can affect students’ performance and relationships. To think we can stop all of this by just banning homework makes me wonder why schools still give out homework at all.

People who believe that homework should not be banned have reasonable points and arguments. They believe that doing homework at home can be better for the students and they would receive higher results. 

They also think the parents of the students will have an idea of what type of work they are doing in the classroom, at what scale the student is doing their work and how the student is doing that work. There is absolutely no reason why parents shouldn’t know what the student’s work is like. 

Some people believe that homework boosts interaction between a student and his or her teacher. Homework might develop their presentation skills. They believe that homework is “a remedy against weaknesses”. These can all be done at school. They believe it teaches the students responsibility because they have to make sure that they do their work and not lose it or destroy it. 

They think the students learn much more new information as well as in school. So people think it teaches the students important life skills. They also think it keeps the students busy and entertained. I would argue that these should all be the responsibility of parents, not school.

A shift in the debate

The Green Party in Ireland has promised to explore the banning of homework for primary school children. They also vow to review primary and secondary schools curriculum “to meet the needs of the 21st century”. Catherine Martin, deputy leader of the Green Party, said that “the phasing out of homework is something that definitely should be explored”. 

“This isn’t new, this has been on our policy for the past several years. And I think we really need to have a conversation on how best to develop the creative juices of our children, or really change how we do homework, homework could be, ‘go home and draw a picture of something that means a lot to you’,” she said.

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

“They’re so young, especially up to the age of seven or eight, it’s a conversation that we need to have”. 

She used the example of Loreto Primary School in Rathfarnham, Dublin, which is currently trialling a “no-homework” programme for all classes except sixth. Ms Martin said that they had found the pilot scheme “amazing” and children were spending a lot more time with their families as a result. 

Mental health considerations

Psychotherapist Mary McHugh believes that we are reducing children’s natural “curious, imaginative and creative” tendencies by “pressuring them to conform”. 

“Our children from the age of three, are being trained to sit still and from five upwards, it’s expected that this is the norm.” McHugh also says that “stress is showing up at an alarming scale and we’re still applying more pressure academically younger and younger”. 

Let’s look at Finland. In Finland, there is no homework in all schools. Finland agrees that there should be no homework because it increases stress, it wastes time etc. Finnish students regularly top the charts on global education metric systems.

Some 93% of Finnish students graduate from secondary school compared to 75% in the USA and 78% in Canada. About two in every three students in Finland go to college which is the highest rate in Europe. The students’ test scores dominate everyone else.  These are the scores for the PISA test (Program for International Student Assessment) 2006.  There are other reasons why Finland’s education system is so good but no homework is definitely an important one. 

Homework increases stress levels among students. It replaces time for hobbies and sports. It messes up your sleep. It can’t always be done and that causes trouble. It’s repetitive. You can develop health problems from lack of sleep.

It takes away time for studying and also when you don’t get enough sleep you can get mood swings and that can affect performance and relationships. There are reasonable arguments for why people who believe that homework shouldn’t be banned are wrong.

We have seen that the Green Party also thinks that homework should be banned and that some schools have already trialled it. We have looked at Finland banning homework and we have seen the impact it has made compared to other countries. This is why I think homework should be banned, not just in my school but in all schools. 

Misha McEnaney is a fifth class student at St Mary’s College, Rathmines, Dublin.

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

Making a difference

A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation..

For the price of one cup of coffee each week you can make sure we can keep reliable, meaningful news open to everyone regardless of their ability to pay.

To embed this post, copy the code below on your site

600px wide <iframe width="600" height="460" frameborder="0" style="border:0px;" src="https://www.thejournal.ie/https://www.thejournal.ie/readme/homework-5086000-May2020/?embedpost=5086000&width=600&height=460" ></iframe>

400px wide <iframe width="600" height="460" frameborder="0" style="border:0px;" src="https://www.thejournal.ie/https://www.thejournal.ie/readme/homework-5086000-May2020/?embedpost=5086000&width=400&height=460" ></iframe>

300px wide <iframe width="600" height="460" frameborder="0" style="border:0px;" src="https://www.thejournal.ie/https://www.thejournal.ie/readme/homework-5086000-May2020/?embedpost=5086000&width=300&height=460" ></iframe>

One moment...

Create an email alert based on the current article

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

NI 'could be magnet for illegal migrants' after court ruling on Rwanda

Fears have been raised that Northern Ireland could become a 'magnet' for illegal immigration after a bombshell court ruling.

The High Court in Belfast decided yesterday that  parts of the Illegal Migration Act cannot apply in the province because of post-Brexit agreements with the EU.

The intervention could mean it is impossible for the Home Office to deport migrants to Rwanda if they travel to Northern Ireland - although the government has insisted it will appeal. 

The DUP insisted the move underlines the problems with Rishi Sunak 's Windsor Framework deal, suggesting illegal immigrants will head there to dodge being sent to the African state. 

But in a round of interviews this morning, Defence Secretary Grant Shapps insisted Northern Ireland would not be an 'exception to the rule' in the wider UK.  

The row comes amid signs the Rwanda scheme is already having a deterrent effect, with Ireland complaining that migrants are crossing the border to avoid being deported to the African state.

The post-Brexit framework includes a stipulation that there can be no diminution of the rights provisions contained within Northern Ireland's Good Friday peace agreement of 1998.

The Illegal Migration Act provides new powers for the Government to detain and remove asylum seekers it deems to have arrived illegally in the UK. Central to the new laws is the scheme to send asylum seekers to Rwanda.

Downing Street suggested the court was wrong to 'extend' post-Brexit rules to cover issues such as illegal migration. 

Mr Sunak said: 'I have been consistently clear that the commitments in the Belfast (Good Friday) Agreement should be interpreted as they were always intended, and not expanded to cover issues like illegal migration. We will take all steps to defend that position, including through appeal.

'This judgment changes nothing about our operational plans to send illegal migrants to Rwanda this July or the lawfulness of our Safety of Rwanda Act.

'We continue to work to get regular flights off to Rwanda in the coming weeks and nothing will distract us from that or delivering to the timetable I set out. We must start the flights to stop the boats.'

The PM's official spokesman said the ruling would have no impact on the first flights to Rwanda planned for this summer as the initial 'cohort' of deportees would be detained under different legislation.

'We continue to work on the timetable that the Prime Minister had previously set out,' he said. 

'We've consistently been clear that the commitment to the Belfast/Good Friday Agreement should be interpreted as they were always intended and not expanded to cover issues like illegal migration.'

A government source said: 'It shows again that the courts are desperate to frustrate this plan, but in the PM's view it is politicians not the courts who are accountable to the public for addressing concerns on illegal migration. We will not be knocked off course.'

But DUP leader Gavin Robinson said the party had warned that the Windsor Framework would block the Rwanda plan in the province.

'It is imperative that immigration policy applies equally across every part of the United Kingdom,' he said. 

'As Unionists, we are clear that our national parliament should have the ability to make decisions on immigration that are applicable on a national basis. 

'If that were not the case, it would not only be a constitutional affront but would make Northern Ireland a magnet for asylum seekers seeking to escape enforcement.' 

Labour peer Baroness Hoey told GB News: 'I presume it will go to the Supreme Court, but I would be very surprised if the Supreme Court takes a different view. Because everyone who understood it and read about Article Two of the protocol knew that this could not apply. 

'Northern Ireland is going to be a magnet for people to come over and I just would warn any government who's thinking of putting in checks on people, they are entering into a very dangerous territory.' 

Solicitor Sinead Marmion, who represented a 16-year-old Iranian asylum seeker in the case, said the judgment was 'hugely significant' and would prevent the Rwanda scheme applying in Northern Ireland.

'This is a huge thorn in the Government's side and it has completely put a spanner in the works,' she added.

MailOnline logo

comscore

School homework: Does it have any benefit at all?

One of the lessons of the past year is that children need different types of learning.

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

‘We need to be far more creative about how we assess ability and we need to be far more inclusive of different skill-sets,’ says psychotherapist Dr Colman Noctor. Photograph: iStock

Jen Hogan's face

When the children returned to school last September I dared to dream, for the short while I was allowed, that homework might be a thing of the past. Our afternoons and evenings were our own, the kids were more content going to school in spite of all the necessary changes, and things were certainly less fractious around the dining-room table. Had the pandemic finally seen off the one thing that many parents had longed to see the back of for years?

Alas, it was not to be. Just a few short weeks later, the dreaded homework returned – and, with it, the familiar dip in the afternoon mood.

As my troops returned in staggered sequence to school this time around, excitement levels were just as high as last September. They’d missed their friends, teachers, classroom learning and routine. In fact they’d missed every single thing about school except homework. The time, however, there was no homework honeymoon period.

There's nothing any more to suggest that the kind of homework we were getting when we were in school is in any way beneficial at all for the children who are doing it

With many parents, teachers and mental health professionals against the idea of homework for primary-school children, you’d have to wonder why we continue with it at all.

Age-based vaccine policy ‘simple’ and country can open quicker – Varadkar

Age-based vaccine policy ‘simple’ and country can open quicker – Varadkar

Europe’s Covid vaccine rollout ‘unacceptably slow’, WHO says

Europe’s Covid vaccine rollout ‘unacceptably slow’, WHO says

German town’s ‘day pass’ gambit offers alternative to Covid restrictions

German town’s ‘day pass’ gambit offers alternative to Covid restrictions

"Tradition is the simple answer" says Simon Lewis, principal of Carlow Educate Together school. "People don't like the absence of something that's been going on for a long time.

“There’s just nothing any more to suggest that the kind of homework we were getting when we were in school is in any way beneficial at all for the children who are doing it. Much like everything else in education, we either have to evolve what we’re doing to suit the needs of today or we have to scrap things that make no sense any more.”

Instead of the traditional homework we’ve come to know and loathe, Lewis would rather see children “getting good at whatever floats their boat”.

“You’ve got people who’d be very traditional and conservative in their views and have lots of arguments as to why we should keep homework. I spend a lot of my time debunking all those myths.”

One such myth, Lewis says, is the argument that homework is good at preparing pupils for secondary school. “It’s a very weak argument. Even logically it makes no sense.” He dismisses the notion that “a child isn’t going to know what to do because they didn’t have eight years of it previously”. Otherwise no child would be capable of taking up a new foreign language at secondary school, for example.

Anything that tends to their mental health is where I want to be focusing my energy this year, and that doesn't include homework

“I get asked about reading. That’s always a counterargument, and it’s probably the best counterargument that I’ve heard. But, again, everybody doing the same thing, everybody reading the same thing, just doesn’t make any sense, because children have different interests; children have different levels of reading. Even families have different interests.”

Lewis has banned spellings and tables at his school, because “there are so many better ways to learn, and learning lists of things off by heart is no way”. He says that there are benefits to parents being kept up to date with what’s going on in school but that the apps used during remote learning facilitate this. “I’d like to think that most schools have now reasonably well-established models for contacting parents.”

Lewis believes his feelings about homework are common among principals. He gave a presentation a couple of years ago at the Irish Primary Principals Network conference, he says, where a straw poll was done. More than 90 per cent of principals said they would get rid of homework immediately if they could. “I think we’re just waiting for somebody to pull the plug on it, but we’d have to be backed up to do it, because it’s so emotive.”

Emer O’Connor says homework for her children will “typically take an hour”. “Although teachers say the homework should only take a short amount of time, this is not my experience. The children are tired and distracted.

“The homework is usually the same every day, so they are not excited about it. It’s a chore that just has to be done, and the parent is the one who has to cajole, pressure, force, bribe, etc. It drives a wedge between parents and their children and has a negative effect on their relationships,” she says.

“They need this time outside more now than they ever did before. They are sitting at their desks more. Classroom movement is hugely restricted. There are more rules to adhere to. They have no drama, music, playball or GAA. Even outside school their activities are curtailed due to Covid.

“The very last thing I want to do when they come home from school is to tell them that they have to sit back down again at the table to do more work. Now more than ever we are being encouraged to tend to our children’s mental health. Anything that tends to their mental health is where I want to be focusing my energy this year, and that doesn’t include homework.”

O’Connor says she would love to see schools look at this “with fresh eyes and make it something that works for our school and our families”.

Taoiseach Micheál Martin has said there will be no homework for children on April 12th. While it’s a start, Starcamp summer-camp owner Aideen O’Grady says she “strongly and categorically believes” it’s time for homework to become a thing of the past for primary-school children.

Parents and students have had enough of kitchen-table schoolwork this year – the focus between Easter and summer should be on wellbeing

“By the time they get home from school, at around 3 or 3.30pm, they eat, and then it’s straight out with the books until dinner time, by when they are exhausted. It’s often stressful, tiring and repetitive.

“Children should be allowed to be children. To simply play, to engage in sport, to be challenged and to challenge, to use their imaginations, to create, to listen to music, to be at one with nature, to find fun, to push boundaries, to find themselves, to lose themselves, to be with their friends, to climb trees, build fairy gardens or forts, to find solutions to real life situations, to fall and pick themselves up, to learn to think outside the box, to communicate more, chat with parents, grandparents, neighbours, to find out who they are, where their talents lie and what they love about life.”

O’Grady says not enough emphasis is put on balance for children. “If this pandemic has taught us anything, it’s to enjoy life as much as we can – and this should include children, who have suffered enough. Sometimes people keep doing what has always been done, without evaluation or an upgrade. Homework is one of those things that has gone without change for far too long. Has anyone stepped up and truly reconsidered the benefits of children being free for what is only a few hours after school?”

Dr Colman Noctor, a child and adolescent psychotherapist, says he does not see the purpose of starting homework "so early and so stringently" and believes homework at primary school at the moment is not a good idea. "Parents and students have had enough of kitchen-table schoolwork this year – the focus between Easter and summer should be on wellbeing.

“I work off a cost-benefit-analysis philosophy, and while the benefits are minimal for some, the costs of homework are great for others. I am fully aware that my role as a psychotherapist means my view is skewed by the fact that I only hear about the problems with most things, but the stories from parents and children about homework are unanimously negative. The argument and stress that these tasks cause some families is phenomenal.

“What I have learned is that ... lots of homework stresses the studious, conscientious child out and causes the unenthusiastic child to opt out.”

Noctor believes there are lessons to be taken from the pandemic and school closures. “What the last year has taught us is that our education system is a very narrow measurement which rewards the child who is engaged, well-supported and has a proclivity for rote learning and a good memory. What we have also learned is that if you are not that type of learner, then tough luck.

“We need to be far more ambitious about what we understand learning to be. We need to be far more creative about how we assess ability, and we need to be far more inclusive of different skill sets. For me, homework and the traditional Leaving Cert are borne out of the same ideology, one that values compliance over engagement.”

‘We’re getting down to bare bones’: Relief as Fota Wildlife Park to reopen in April

Covid-19: government row erupts over plan to expand mandatory quarantine, pressing need to explain vaccine priority list changes, says norma foley, has covid-19 robbed us of our illusions, what did 3 million people learn from this online happiness course, let there be light: why sunny spring days make us happier and healthier, our first vaccination clinic: no dissenters, no complaints, only smiles, in this section, carl mullan: ‘it’s such a shock to the system becoming a parent’, ‘i would like now to share my tips on how you too can become an unbearably smug runner’, ‘it’s great to be able to do kidney dialysis in my sleep . . . i can live my life with this’, whooping cough q&a: what is the disease, and what should i do if my child has it, parent’s benefit scheme: option of taking leave remains outside the grasp of many fathers, moving back to ireland would mean working till 10pm, no home of my own and bad coffee, wolfe tones lead singer sues rté for defamation over comments made by joe duffy on liveline, woman’s 30-year ‘vendetta’ against brother over farm is ‘worst example of weaponisation’ of courts, slovak pm in life-threatening condition after being shot in ‘politically motivated’ assassination attempt, dublin pizza restaurant ranked 15th in top 20 european pizzerias, latest stories, st john’s ambulance child abuse survivors claim charity has failed to implement reforms.

St John’s Ambulance child abuse survivors claim charity has failed to implement reforms

‘We want to raise the next generation of Irish speakers’ committee told

‘We want to raise the next generation of Irish speakers’ committee told

Former Domino’s worker awarded €19,000 in sexual harassment case

Former Domino’s worker awarded €19,000 in sexual harassment case

Tánaiste to pursue case of Pte Seán Rooney during visit to Lebanon, conference told

Tánaiste to pursue case of Pte Seán Rooney during visit to Lebanon, conference told

Decision on Garda file relating to 2017 death of Jamie Tighe Ennis in Dublin expected within months

Decision on Garda file relating to 2017 death of Jamie Tighe Ennis in Dublin expected within months

‘This is heartbreaking’: Migrant workers protest over rules on family reunions

‘This is heartbreaking’: Migrant workers protest over rules on family reunions

UK Covid-19 inquiry: Arlene Foster rejects claim Stormont leaders ‘sleepwalked’ into pandemic

UK Covid-19 inquiry: Arlene Foster rejects claim Stormont leaders ‘sleepwalked’ into pandemic

The Irish Times view on the new business support package: some help but many will still struggle

The Irish Times view on the new business support package: some help but many will still struggle

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Information
  • Cookie Settings
  • Community Standards

Tory minister says UK government 'won't let Northern Ireland be exception' to Rwanda scheme

Tory minister says UK government 'won't let Northern Ireland be exception' to Rwanda scheme

UK defence secretary Grant Shapps. File Picture: PA

The British government will not allow Northern Ireland to be the exception to the UK’s Rwanda scheme after a court judgment in Belfast, UK defence secretary Grant Shapps has told GB News.

On Monday, a judge has ruled that provisions of the UK’s Illegal Migration Act should be disapplied in Northern Ireland, as they undermine human rights protections guaranteed in the region under post-Brexit arrangements.

Mr Justice Humphreys also said aspects of the Act were incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).

The British government has vowed to appeal over the ruling and has insisted the court judgment will not derail or delay its contentious Rwanda scheme.

“We will ensure we will do everything that’s required to make sure … that Northern Ireland can’t be in this position. Because we believe firmly in being able to control our own borders," Mr Shapps told GB News .

“We are absolutely going to appeal that ruling.

“We won’t let Northern Ireland be an exception – exemption – to the rule in the United Kingdom.”

The post-Brexit Windsor Framework jointly agreed by the UK and EU includes a stipulation that there can be no diminution of the rights provisions contained within Northern Ireland’s Good Friday peace agreement of 1998.

Belfast High Court. File Picture: PA

The Illegal Migration Act provides new powers for the UK government to detain and remove asylum seekers it deems to have arrived illegally in the UK. Central to the new laws is the scheme to send asylum seekers to Rwanda.

Mr Justice Humphreys delivered judgment at Belfast High Court on Monday in two challenges against the Act that focused on the peace process human rights protections guaranteed by the Windsor Framework.

Each of the statutory provisions under consideration infringes the protection afforded to RSE (Rights, Safeguards and Equality of Opportunity) in the Belfast/Good Friday Agreement

The judge found that several elements of the Act do cause a “significant” diminution of the rights enjoyed by asylum seekers residing in Northern Ireland under the terms of the Good Friday Agreement.

“I have found that there is a relevant diminution of right in each of the areas relied upon by the applicants,” he said.

He added: “The applicants’ primary submission therefore succeeds. Each of the statutory provisions under consideration infringes the protection afforded to RSE (Rights, Safeguards and Equality of Opportunity) in the Belfast/Good Friday Agreement.”

The judge ruled that the sections of the Act that were the subject of the legal challenges should be “disapplied” in Northern Ireland.

He also declared aspects of the Act incompatible with the ECHR.

One of the cases was taken by the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission and the other by a 16-year-old asylum seeker from Iran who is living in Northern Ireland having arrived in the UK as an unaccompanied child.

The boy, who travelled from France by small boat and claimed asylum in July 2023, has said he would be killed or sent to prison if he returned to Iran.

The judge agreed to place a temporary stay on the disapplication ruling until another hearing at the end of May, when the applicants will have an opportunity to respond to the judgment.

Downing Street said the British government would challenge the ruling, but insisted its overall plan for sending asylum seekers to Rwanda would not be affected.

It suggested the rights provisions of the Good Friday Agreement were never intended to cover issues such as “illegal migration”.

The UK prime minister’s official spokesman said on Monday: “This judgment doesn’t affect our operational plans to send illegal migrants to Rwanda or the lawfulness of our Safety of Rwanda Act.

“We continue to work on the timetable that the Prime Minister had previously set out.

“We’ve consistently been clear that the commitment to the Belfast/Good Friday Agreement should be interpreted as they were always intended and not expanded to cover issues like illegal migration.

“We will take all steps to defend that position including through appeal.”

is it illegal to have homework in ireland

Outside court, solicitor Sinead Marmion, who represented the teenage Iranian asylum seeker applicant, said the judgment was “hugely significant”.

Ms Marmion said the judgment would prevent the Rwanda scheme applying in Northern Ireland.

“This is a huge thorn in the Government’s side and it has completely put a spanner in the works,” she told the PA news agency.

“There’s a huge obstacle in the way of them being able to actually implement that in Northern Ireland now, as it’s been found to be incompatible with the Windsor Framework.”

In a statement, the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission said: “The commission issued this legal challenge in its own name due to the significant concerns it has with the Illegal Migration Act and the effect on asylum seekers in Northern Ireland.

“We will now be considering the judgment in full and its implications.”

WhatsApp logo

Irish Examiner’s WhatsApp channel

Follow and share the latest news and stories

more brexit articles

Keir Starmer visit to Dover

More in this section

House prices rose by more than 7% over last year

Irish boy blown away as David Attenborough writes to aspiring young wildlife photographer

Lunchtime news.

Sign up to the best reads of the week from irishexaminer.com selected just for you.

Please click  here for our privacy statement.

War_map

Jennifer Horgan

For a fresh perspective on life today

Inquest into the deaths of Nicola Keane and her 7 month old son Henry Coleman

Wednesday, May 15, 2024 - 3:00 PM

Patrick Horgan and Fergal O’Connor 11/5/2024

Wednesday, May 15, 2024 - 1:00 PM

Wimbledon 2018 - Day Nine - The All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club

Wednesday, May 15, 2024 - 9:00 AM

Fergus Finlay

Fergus Finlay

Family Notices

Family Notices

© Examiner Echo Group Limited

IMAGES

  1. 15 Major Reasons Why Homework Should Be Banned

    is it illegal to have homework in ireland

  2. Is Homework Illegal Anywhere in the World?

    is it illegal to have homework in ireland

  3. Petition · Ban on homework in ireland · Change.org

    is it illegal to have homework in ireland

  4. Is Homework Illegal? [Reasons Why Homework Should Be Banned]

    is it illegal to have homework in ireland

  5. Is Homework Illegal?

    is it illegal to have homework in ireland

  6. Petition · Ban homework for all schools in ireland

    is it illegal to have homework in ireland

VIDEO

  1. Shouldn’t Homework also be ILLEGAL? 🤔

COMMENTS

  1. President Higgins calls for homework to be banned in Ireland

    President Michael D Higgins (Image: Niall Carson/PA Wire) President Michal D Higgins has called for homework to be banned. The country's favourite leader has given hope to a new generation of ...

  2. Students and parents plead case for homework ban

    Many kids have had to stop doing hobbies they have because of it. "It is a burden to parents, kids, and teachers [and] so for the above reasons, I think you should BAN HOMEWORK!" Homework ...

  3. President Michael D Higgins says homework should be banned in Ireland

    President Michael D Higgins has called for homework to be banned. The country's favourite leader has given hope to a new generation of students that the bane of their afterschool evenings could ...

  4. Irish Mirror readers overwhelmingly back President's call for 'homework

    Read More: President Higgins calls for homework to be banned in Ireland We asked "Should homework be banned?", which was answered with a 98% majority, Yes. In a landslide decision, 57,440 readers ...

  5. President of Ireland calls on schools to stop giving pupils homework

    Schools should strive not to give pupils homework where possible, the president of Ireland has suggested.. In an utterance likely to be seized upon by children for years to come, in classrooms far ...

  6. Two primary school principals debate a homework ban

    Whilst I get that homework can be a stress point for many parents returning from work at night, the truth is that Irish children have never been more likely to be involved in after-school clubs ...

  7. President tells children of Ireland what he really thinks about homework

    A smile is likely to have cross children and teenagers' faces after the president of Ireland suggested that homework should be scrapped. Read More Related Articles. Explainer: Why political ...

  8. President Michael D Higgins calls for school homework to be scrapped

    President of Ireland Michael D Higgins has said he supports the scrapping of homework. He addressed students of St Kevin's National School, Littleton, Co Tipperary, this week in an episode of RTE's news2day programme. The President said that schoolwork should be completed in school time so children can use time after school to pursue more ...

  9. School Curriculum

    - The role of homework - Homework and achievement - Parental involvement with homework. Children's voice on homework. In terms of recommendations related to homework, the following are detailed: - Additional opportunities could be provided for parents and teachers to discuss how to support children's language development in the home.

  10. Why homework has merit and can be a force for good

    Homework is an important bridge between school and the home. It allows parents to be part of a child's educational journey and to contribute in a meaningful way. I come, not to bury homework ...

  11. Why do parents allow children to continue doing homework when they can

    Homework is back with a bang, bringing with it the familiar sense of dread for children and parents alike. It encroaches on precious and limited family time and it can establish an unhealthy work ...

  12. Schoolchildren and parents urge minister to introduce homework ban

    Schoolchildren and parents have pleaded with Education Minister Norma Foley to step in and introduce a homework ban. In letters to the minister, children wrote about how they were being forced to ...

  13. President of Ireland calls for homework to be banned

    The President of Ireland has made his thoughts known about homework, saying it should be left at the gate and children should be able to use their leisure time for "creative things". Speaking to RTE's news2day - a current affairs and news programme for children, Michael D Higgins answered questions on a wide range of topics, the Irish Mirror ...

  14. Banning homework: Taoiseach says schoolchildren get too much homework

    Varadkar added that he "definitely" think kids have "too much homework". "You could have a long day in class, get home in the early evening and then face three hours of homework.

  15. Norma Foley won't debate homework with President Michael Higgins after

    It comes days after President Higgins' call for homework to be banned at home and for all work to stay in the classroom. Irish Mirror readers were also overwhelmingly in favour of banning ...

  16. Banning homework: Norma Foley won't debate homework issue with

    Minister for Education, Norma Foley, has said she won't debate the homework ban issue with President Michael D Higgins.. School policy on homework. Last week, Higgins told the nation's children ...

  17. Homework Ban: Parents and children call on Foley to ban homework

    Foley has received multiple letters from both children and parents about why a homework ban is needed. According to The Irish Examiner, children revealed that homework is having a negative impact on their lives outside of school.. Many pupils believe they do enough work in school and stressed that there is little benefit to spending hours doing homework in the evenings.

  18. The Irish school that doesn't believe in homework

    One Dublin primary school's 'no-homework policy' has been a resounding success. Teacher Eimear O'Callaghan with 4th class pupils at Loreto Primary School, Rathfarnham. Photograph Nick ...

  19. PDF Experiences and Opinions of Parents Regarding Homework in Irish ...

    Ireland tells us that 96 percent of Irish children receive homework four nights a week (Williams et al., 2009). However, there is no official homework policy in Ireland. In 2019, all three of the daily broadsheet newspapers in Ireland published think-pieces on homework, largely positioning it as either completely unnecessary, or as a necessary evil

  20. 'Why I believe homework should be banned', by one primary school student

    We have looked at Finland banning homework and we have seen the impact it has made compared to other countries. This is why I think homework should be banned, not just in my school but in all schools.

  21. Stuff

    President of Ireland calls for homework to be banned | Stuff.co.nzHow would you feel if your homework was cancelled for good? That's what the President of Ireland, Michael D. Higgins, suggested in ...

  22. Here's why Ireland is at boiling point over mass immigration

    Hundreds of protests in towns have sprung up in Ireland with people calling on the government to end what they say is an "open borders" globalist agenda that is putting the needs of migrants ahead ...

  23. Taoiseach backs plans to increase legal smoking age in Republic ...

    Smoking levels among adults in Ireland are reported to have plateaued at around 18%. ... "We're not talking about making something illegal that is legal today," he said. "So in other words ...

  24. NI 'could be magnet for illegal migrants' after court ruling on ...

    The Illegal Migration Act provides new powers for the Government to detain and remove asylum seekers it deems to have arrived illegally in the UK. Central to the new laws is the scheme to send ...

  25. Afternoon angst: is homework really necessary?

    It conducted an online survey of more than 5,000 parents in 2016, the results of which illustrated the extent of homework angst in Irish homes. Some 58 per cent of parents of children in the four ...

  26. PSNI in plea for help to catch predatory money lenders

    The PSNI has urged the public to help bring more predatory money lenders before the courts. Just three people have been prosecuted by the Paramilitary Crime Task Force for illegal money lending in ...

  27. School homework: Does it have any benefit at all?

    There's nothing any more to suggest that the kind of homework we were getting when we were in school is in any way beneficial at all for the children who are doing it. With many parents, teachers ...

  28. Provisions of UK's Illegal Migration Act should be disapplied in

    The Illegal Migration Act provides new powers for the UK government to detain and remove asylum seekers it deems to have arrived illegally in the UK. Central to the new laws is the scheme to send ...

  29. The 'Dark Fleet' powering Putin's Ukraine war machine is out of hand

    There's some indication that naval presence can deter some of the most egregious behaviour: two days ago the Greek Navy conducted a naval exercise in the Laconian Gulf, a regular place for ship ...