Literature reviews are foundational to any study. They describe what is known about given topic and lead us to identify a knowledge gap to study. All reviews require authors to be able accurately summarize, synthesize, interpret and even critique the research literature. 1, 2 In fact, for this editorial we have had to review the literature on ...
Writing an Article Critique
Before you start writing, you will need to take some steps to get ready for your critique: Choose an article that meets the criteria outlined by your instructor. Read the article to get an understanding of the main idea. Read the article again with a critical eye. As you read, take note of the following: What are the credentials of the author/s?
Evaluate and critique the literature
This guide focuses on the searching for literature step of the literature review process. Conducting your search, storing and organising the literature and evaluating what you find. Planning your search strategy and how to find, store, organise, evaluate and critique information for your literature review.
PDF CRITIQUING LITERATURE
THE LITERATURE REVIEW The literature review should give an overview of the available literature which frames or surrounds the problem being researched. It should look at the similarities and differences between the literature, as well as the strengths and limitations. It should illustrate how the current study fits into the existing framework of
Critically reviewing literature: A tutorial for new researchers
Systematic reviews must critique the literature that is found. According to Torraco (2005), being critical goes beyond identifying strengths e.g. the development and consistent use of improved measures for the key construct) ... Instead, a literature review for an empirical article or for a thesis is usually organized by concept. However, a ...
Writing an article CRITIQUE
A critique asks you to evaluate an article and the author's argument. You will need to look critically at what the author is claiming, evaluate the research methods, and look for possible problems with, or applications of, the researcher's claims. Introduction. Give an overview of the author's main points and how the author supports those ...
How to Write a Literature Review
Examples of literature reviews. Step 1 - Search for relevant literature. Step 2 - Evaluate and select sources. Step 3 - Identify themes, debates, and gaps. Step 4 - Outline your literature review's structure. Step 5 - Write your literature review.
Guidance on Conducting a Systematic Literature Review
Critique: All literature types: Critical review: Grant and Booth 2009: Dieckmann, Malle, and Bodner 2009: Dieckmann, Malle, and Bodner (2009) provide an example of a critical review examining the reporting and practices of meta-analyses in psychology and related fields. The review compares the amassed group of literature in the subfields to a ...
Critical literature reviews: A critique and actionable advice
This article treats critical literature reviews as a distinct review type, and presents a critique of author-labeled critical literature reviews in Organization and Management Studies. We identify and problematize 275 review articles that claim to critically review a body of literature and find that most to not deliver on this claim.
Writing a literature review
A formal literature review is an evidence-based, in-depth analysis of a subject. There are many reasons for writing one and these will influence the length and style of your review, but in essence a literature review is a critical appraisal of the current collective knowledge on a subject. Rather than just being an exhaustive list of all that ...
Writing Critical Reviews: A Step-by-Step Guide
A critical review (some times called a summary and critique) is similar to a liter ature review (see Chapter 1 5, Writing a Literature Review ) , except that it i s a review of one article.
Writing a Literature Review
The lit review is an important genre in many disciplines, not just literature (i.e., the study of works of literature such as novels and plays). When we say "literature review" or refer to "the literature," we are talking about the research (scholarship) in a given field. You will often see the terms "the research," "the ...
Literature review as a research methodology: An ...
As mentioned previously, there are a number of existing guidelines for literature reviews. Depending on the methodology needed to achieve the purpose of the review, all types can be helpful and appropriate to reach a specific goal (for examples, please see Table 1).These approaches can be qualitative, quantitative, or have a mixed design depending on the phase of the review.
PDF Step'by-step guide to critiquing research. Part 1: quantitative research
A critique is an impersonal evaluation of the strengths and limitations of the research being reviewed and should not be seen as a disparagement of the researchers ability. Neither should it be regarded as ... through the literature review, the theoretical framework, the research question, the methodology section, the data analysis, and the ...
How to Review a Journal Article
For many kinds of assignments, like a literature review, you may be asked to offer a critique or review of a journal article.This is an opportunity for you as a scholar to offer your qualified opinion and evaluation of how another scholar has composed their article, argument, and research.That means you will be expected to go beyond a simple summary of the article and evaluate it on a deeper ...
Critical Analysis: The Often-Missing Step in Conducting Literature
Reporting guidelines are focused on the product created—the literature review article. Their purpose is to establish a guide for authors, editors and readers to use in determining the transparency and quality of scholarly literature reviews while reducing potential bias. ... Analysis refers to the assessment, or critique, of the literature (p ...
Ten Simple Rules for Writing a Literature Review
Literature reviews are in great demand in most scientific fields. Their need stems from the ever-increasing output of scientific publications .For example, compared to 1991, in 2008 three, eight, and forty times more papers were indexed in Web of Science on malaria, obesity, and biodiversity, respectively .Given such mountains of papers, scientists cannot be expected to examine in detail every ...
How to Critique a Research Article
Undertaking a critique of a research article may seem challenging at first, but will help you to evaluate whether the article has relevance to your own practice and workplace. Reading a single article can act as a springboard into researching the topic more widely, and aids in ensuring your nursing practice remains current and is supported by existing literature.
(PDF) Critiquing Reviewed Literature
Slide 1. Critiquing Reviewed Literature. Dr Jens J. Hansen. Dr Richard Smith. In our experie nce, encountering a poo rly constructed and ge nerally uncritical literature review remains. an all too ...
How to Critique an Article. Guide With Structure & Example
Provide a brief description of why it is important in your specific context. Next, remember to mention all the interesting aspects that help to reveal the value of the article. Finally, talk about the author's intention and vision regarding the subject. The final part of the article critique must offer a summary of the main purpose. Learning ...
COMMENTS
Literature reviews are foundational to any study. They describe what is known about given topic and lead us to identify a knowledge gap to study. All reviews require authors to be able accurately summarize, synthesize, interpret and even critique the research literature. 1, 2 In fact, for this editorial we have had to review the literature on ...
Before you start writing, you will need to take some steps to get ready for your critique: Choose an article that meets the criteria outlined by your instructor. Read the article to get an understanding of the main idea. Read the article again with a critical eye. As you read, take note of the following: What are the credentials of the author/s?
This guide focuses on the searching for literature step of the literature review process. Conducting your search, storing and organising the literature and evaluating what you find. Planning your search strategy and how to find, store, organise, evaluate and critique information for your literature review.
THE LITERATURE REVIEW The literature review should give an overview of the available literature which frames or surrounds the problem being researched. It should look at the similarities and differences between the literature, as well as the strengths and limitations. It should illustrate how the current study fits into the existing framework of
Systematic reviews must critique the literature that is found. According to Torraco (2005), being critical goes beyond identifying strengths e.g. the development and consistent use of improved measures for the key construct) ... Instead, a literature review for an empirical article or for a thesis is usually organized by concept. However, a ...
A critique asks you to evaluate an article and the author's argument. You will need to look critically at what the author is claiming, evaluate the research methods, and look for possible problems with, or applications of, the researcher's claims. Introduction. Give an overview of the author's main points and how the author supports those ...
Examples of literature reviews. Step 1 - Search for relevant literature. Step 2 - Evaluate and select sources. Step 3 - Identify themes, debates, and gaps. Step 4 - Outline your literature review's structure. Step 5 - Write your literature review.
Critique: All literature types: Critical review: Grant and Booth 2009: Dieckmann, Malle, and Bodner 2009: Dieckmann, Malle, and Bodner (2009) provide an example of a critical review examining the reporting and practices of meta-analyses in psychology and related fields. The review compares the amassed group of literature in the subfields to a ...
This article treats critical literature reviews as a distinct review type, and presents a critique of author-labeled critical literature reviews in Organization and Management Studies. We identify and problematize 275 review articles that claim to critically review a body of literature and find that most to not deliver on this claim.
A formal literature review is an evidence-based, in-depth analysis of a subject. There are many reasons for writing one and these will influence the length and style of your review, but in essence a literature review is a critical appraisal of the current collective knowledge on a subject. Rather than just being an exhaustive list of all that ...
A critical review (some times called a summary and critique) is similar to a liter ature review (see Chapter 1 5, Writing a Literature Review ) , except that it i s a review of one article.
The lit review is an important genre in many disciplines, not just literature (i.e., the study of works of literature such as novels and plays). When we say "literature review" or refer to "the literature," we are talking about the research (scholarship) in a given field. You will often see the terms "the research," "the ...
As mentioned previously, there are a number of existing guidelines for literature reviews. Depending on the methodology needed to achieve the purpose of the review, all types can be helpful and appropriate to reach a specific goal (for examples, please see Table 1).These approaches can be qualitative, quantitative, or have a mixed design depending on the phase of the review.
A critique is an impersonal evaluation of the strengths and limitations of the research being reviewed and should not be seen as a disparagement of the researchers ability. Neither should it be regarded as ... through the literature review, the theoretical framework, the research question, the methodology section, the data analysis, and the ...
For many kinds of assignments, like a literature review, you may be asked to offer a critique or review of a journal article.This is an opportunity for you as a scholar to offer your qualified opinion and evaluation of how another scholar has composed their article, argument, and research.That means you will be expected to go beyond a simple summary of the article and evaluate it on a deeper ...
Reporting guidelines are focused on the product created—the literature review article. Their purpose is to establish a guide for authors, editors and readers to use in determining the transparency and quality of scholarly literature reviews while reducing potential bias. ... Analysis refers to the assessment, or critique, of the literature (p ...
Literature reviews are in great demand in most scientific fields. Their need stems from the ever-increasing output of scientific publications .For example, compared to 1991, in 2008 three, eight, and forty times more papers were indexed in Web of Science on malaria, obesity, and biodiversity, respectively .Given such mountains of papers, scientists cannot be expected to examine in detail every ...
Undertaking a critique of a research article may seem challenging at first, but will help you to evaluate whether the article has relevance to your own practice and workplace. Reading a single article can act as a springboard into researching the topic more widely, and aids in ensuring your nursing practice remains current and is supported by existing literature.
Slide 1. Critiquing Reviewed Literature. Dr Jens J. Hansen. Dr Richard Smith. In our experie nce, encountering a poo rly constructed and ge nerally uncritical literature review remains. an all too ...
Provide a brief description of why it is important in your specific context. Next, remember to mention all the interesting aspects that help to reveal the value of the article. Finally, talk about the author's intention and vision regarding the subject. The final part of the article critique must offer a summary of the main purpose. Learning ...